1. Statements: Conclusions, Assumptions, Courses of Action, Cause and Effect
Critical reasoning questions give a short statement and ask what follows from it, what is taken for granted, what action is sensible, or which event caused another. Answers must come only from the statement, not from your personal opinion.
Conclusions and assumptions
- A conclusion is a fact that must follow from the statement. An assumption is something the speaker takes for granted without saying it.
- Example: 'All students who scored above 90% got a scholarship. Rina did not get a scholarship.' Conclusion: Rina did not score above 90%. It does not follow that Rina skipped the exam.
- Example: notice 'Please switch off the lights before leaving the room.' Assumption: people may forget to switch off the lights. 'Electricity is free' is clearly not assumed.
- An advertisement assumes people want the benefit it offers. 'Use XYZ soap for glowing skin' assumes people want glowing skin.
- Reject options with extreme words like 'only', 'always', 'never', 'all' unless the statement itself uses them.
Courses of action
- A course of action should solve or reduce the problem, be practical and be in proportion to the problem.
- Example: many children fall ill after drinking water from a village well. Testing and cleaning the well water is a good action. Shifting the whole village is too extreme.
- Punishment-only actions (ban everything, close the office forever) are usually not accepted.
- Both actions may follow if both are practical and help in different ways (for example, treat the sick and test the water).
Cause and effect
- You get two events and must decide whether one caused the other, both are independent, or both came from a common cause.
- Example: I. The government reduced the price of diesel. II. Bus fares were reduced in many cities. Diesel is a main cost of buses, so I is the cause and II is its effect.
- Common cause example: I. Schools were closed. II. Many roads were flooded. Both can be effects of heavy rain.
- Check time order: a cause must come before its effect. Ask 'does event A explain event B?'
- Conclusion
- must be true from the statement
- Assumption
- taken for granted, unstated
- Course of action
- practical, solves the problem
- Cause
- comes first and explains the effect
💡 Read the statement twice and ask 'does this option add anything not given?' If yes, it is not a conclusion.
📝 5-question quiz on this lesson: enrol free to take it and track your score.